Teacher’s right to private sexual conduct worth less than school’s ‘reputation’, says teaching regulator.

This post was written by Jon on May 24, 2011
Posted Under: Education,Public Sector,Puritanism,Uncategorized

A primary school teacher has avoided being barred from teaching following revelations in the press of her sideline as a dominatrix, the TES reports.

Faith-Anne Lesbirel, a primary school teacher, was exposed by a tabloid newspaper in 2008 as none other than ‘Mistress Saffron’, a dominatrix offering her services for money online.

[Lesbirel] insisted her fetish activities were private and of “no relevance” to her job, that her presence online was anonymous and she believed her identity was not traceable.

Following the newspaper article, Ms Lesbirel took down her website and admitted her activities to her headteacher, Lynn Samwell-Smith, who was “shocked” but supportive.

Mrs Samwell-Smith, who no longer works at the school, told a General Teaching Council for England (GTC) panel there had been disruption after the news came to light. Some parents told her they did not want Ms Lesbirel having contact with their children; others said her private life had nothing to do with her job.

Mrs Samwell-Smith said there was an “adverse impact” on the school and its reputation. Year 5 and 6 pupils asked Ms Lesbirel if she was a “prostitute”. Eventually the teacher, who had given notice before the incident, opted to leave her job early.

[Read the full thing here: http://bit.ly/mLuK4t]

Lesbirel was given a reprimand by a General Teaching Council for England (GTC) panel, which will stay on her record for two years.

It’s encouraging to see that the reaction from parents wasn’t entirely torches and pitchforks. Unfortunately, it is the ignorance and irrational fear of the more excitable parents that is routinely upheld by the GTC (pictured here: http://bit.ly/jzRUOE). The GTC’s code of conduct has been condemned by teachers’ union NASUWT, as it has been used to discipline teachers for attending gay pride events and having bikini pictures on their facebook accounts. (The code demands “standards of behaviour both inside and outside school [for teachers] that are appropriate given their membership of an important and responsible profession”. My emphasis.)

The comments of the GTC committee that questioned Ms Lesbirel are extraordinary in their contempt for basic ideas of residual freedom and their assumption that it is the Council’s right to police teachers’ private behaviour.

‘You promoted services of a sexual nature via a publicly accessible website that you instigated and you maintained a profile on the “Informed Consent” website, where you say in your written submission you also offered your services as a dominatrix.

‘Anyone could have gained access to these websites. [Children in Years 5 and 6 are accustomed to seeking out dominatrix services online, it seems.]

‘It is clear that the reputation and public standing of the profession was placed at risk by your choosing to initiate and run such a website and indeed the exposure of this did in the event damage the school and the profession. [This information was released, remember, by a tabloid newspaper].

Public trust and confidence was affected.’

[Quoted here: http://bit.ly/mcrTph]

Teachers in this country increasingly bear the brunt of our social and political ills. Pay is being frozen, while funding is cut. Creative and dedicated educators are forced to teach to the test, rather than attempt to inspire, to meet meaningless targets. Teachers are abused and harassed daily by children brutalised by urban squalor and inequality. And now their private conduct is subject to scrutiny from an unelected quango of puritans. Why does anyone sign up for this job?

Like this article? Print it, email it, Stumble, Facebook and Tweet it:
  • Print
  • email
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Mixx
  • Yahoo! Bookmarks
  • Live
Share

Reader Comments

I could not agree more. This is all quite interesting in the context of super injunctions. The General Teaching Council is a semi-statutory body which exercises power on behalf of the state. In the past the “right to privacy” primarily referred not to the constraint in the media, but to a check on the state. The notion of “privacy” meant there were some areas into which the state’s writ did not run. Under new labour, this kind of privacy became increasingly attenuated – Hence the laws against bdsm porn, and indeed the emergence of these guidelines. At the same time, the idea of privacy was increasingly used to constrain civil society, to protect citizens not from the state but from other citizens – by means of greater state power. Hence the emerging privacy law and the Regulation of Investigatory powers Act.

#1 
Written By Reuben on May 24th, 2011 @ 8:32 pm
Hugh

Speaking as a teacher, we have a great deal of *stuff* (I can’t think of a better word to cover how nebulously and insidiously it is slid in) in our training, our syllabi, our pedagogical text books, our guidelines and curricula, and so on and so forth which are designed to make teachers into servants of the government. What you do with your naked body as regards intrusive conformism pales into comparison besides what professional standards expect you to do to your mind.

This is not a new thing, though – it is just more codified and visible because the instrumentalisation of teachers as agents of the dominant discourse comes increasingly under the remit of the democratically accountable Secretary of State and a set of bodies (“the blob”) which the subject knows are designed to operate teachers. What I mean is that these standards were once applied by priests to monks and nuns via canon law, and now are applied by QUANGO officials to schoolteachers via professional guidelines.

A theory of education which takes properly into account the effect that the nature of the teacher and the nature of the learner has upon learning (and within this effect the relationship between teacher and learner) will imply that teachers need to be certain sort of people if we are trying to communicate certain sorts of ideas in certain sorts of ways. All the best theories of education involve such a presumption, and we are always trying to communicate one idea or another (and of necessity we are always using a method to do so). So you could regard controlling teachers’ private lives as an inevitable and often legitimate part of holistic education policy.

#2 
Written By Hugh on May 26th, 2011 @ 5:55 pm

You take the medicines in confidence knowing that what was delivered
to your house was your usual prescription. As incidents of identity theft
increase both online and offline, it has become important for
consumers to be on their guard when it comes to credit card transactions.
Paper records should be shredded so that they can’t be reconstructed.

#3 
Written By http://Www.Wfsb.com on December 13th, 2013 @ 11:23 pm

So what happens if the thief changes your address and you don’t receive your bill.
You are able to do it online or in writing, and you must inform these companies that your identifying
info has been stolen and it is becoming used by another person fraudulently inside your name.
Thieves will ignore the bills and leave you
to pay for them, resulting in your credit standing being ruined and your finances
being at risk.

#4 
Written By identity theft wallet on December 15th, 2013 @ 10:22 pm

This will decrease certain expenses including air fares and
hotel bills. As more and more organizations have grown to be more interested in
developing algorithms which will intelligently analyze conversations, mentions and sharing
to get additional intimate insights on consumer interest, consumer behavior and general market trends (Solis, 2011).
Nike spends $678 million on advertising a year ago, simply a portion of their almost $2 billion spend on total marketing.

#5 
Written By Chadwick on December 17th, 2013 @ 1:31 pm

You need to feel happy and confident in the knickers you choose and despite what magazines
would have you think a pair of pants does not have to be tiny in order to be sexy.
It also tells your friends a whole lot about what sort of wedding to expect.
Events are too short-lived to make up for anything-only
a positive change in the long-term interactions between you and your family
can do that.

#6 
Written By אישורי הגעה לחתונה on December 23rd, 2013 @ 1:12 am

Interestingly, Fer-Eng Investments LLC, of Arizona, also submitted a trademark application for the Occupy Wall Street name.
So let experts show you real-life examples
of how to trade with zero experience. The one place in the
United States you blame for all yours and the countries problems.

#7 
Written By Blog.Com on January 2nd, 2014 @ 1:55 pm

The first step in knowing the way to start a local business online directory service is usually to decide what will be
the focus. While an excellent list builder and autoresponder
will amount to some money upfront, it really is well worth it as being your subscribers,
readers and purchases climb higher. They offer different packages to their customers base on
their own specific needs and within their budget.

#8 
Written By www.sitidelima.com on January 6th, 2014 @ 8:45 pm

Getting an internet site name that’s memorable and unique can be
a way through which you can leave a mark with your customers’ minds.
Once on your own list, you’ve got to constantly provide value
for a subscribers. They offer different packages with their customers
base on their own specific needs as well as within their budget.

#9 
Written By Marketing consultant salary south Africa on January 8th, 2014 @ 2:52 pm

He puts in regular information about bankruptcy lawyer Indianapolis.
A court appointed attorney may not cost the defendant any money or the defendant may receive the
court appointed attorney at reduced fees. ‘
A lawyer can help you guide and prepare you to get citizenship tests that you will need to consider in the future.

#10 
Written By Jerome Karam Attorney on January 20th, 2014 @ 2:50 am

In order to find the best asset to invest in your IRA account, you should be consistent in
choosing the ideal retirement investments that suits your retirement
plan. The older you get the fewer assets you will be buying to live on.
The sale of most Apartment or Multi-unit Properties is ususally simply
a business decision.

#11 
Written By Comprar Oro en Ciudad de buenos Aires on January 24th, 2014 @ 5:41 pm

That is the surest way to undergo a stress free procedure.

Many ‘normal’ ‘ordinary’ people today opt for cosmetic procedures.
It may be necessary for you to use antibiotics for several weeks prior to surgery
in order to lessen the danger of post-operative infection.

#12 
Written By Breast augmentation Naperville on February 12th, 2014 @ 2:50 am

Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I really appreciate your efforts and I am waiting for your next write
ups thank you once again.

#13 
Written By http://Youtube.Com on February 26th, 2014 @ 1:22 am

Add a Comment

required, use real name
required, will not be published
optional, your blog address

Please leave these two fields as-is:

Protected by Invisible Defender. Showed 403 to 446,831 bad guys.